• The absolute best cheesecakes in Evansville, IN

    Welcome to Anthony's Heavenly Cheesecake, the premier cheesecake bakery in the Evansville area. With more than 75 dessert cheesecake flavors, we look forward to having you try a single slice or a whole cheesecake.


    These petite yummies are perfect for sampling our many flavors. Buy 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 ...a dozen! In May we have several flavors available and special offers! Cheesecake minis are the perfect size dessert cheesecakes to serve at your upcoming occasion.

  • Craving a specialty dessert?

    We make our dessert cheesecakes from scratch using Anthony's recipes. The taste of this turtle cheesecake slice will hit the spot and have you craving more! Select flavors every day in the café by the slice. >>Order online now and pick up at our bakery in Evansville.

  • Chocolate Silk Cheesecake

    Many asked for simply chocolate and we answered with this rich and creamy slice of chocolate heaven. Chocolate Silk will accompany Turtle and Anthony's Original every day in the by the slice cooler. Also available to order in 4 inch, 6 inch, 9 inch, minis and bites.

  • The absolute best cheesecakes in Evansville, IN

    Welcome to Anthony's Heavenly Cheesecake, the premier cheesecake bakery in the Evansville area. Anthony's Original started it all ...and now over 75 dessert cheesecake flavors have been created. Order your custom-made cheesecake 72 hours in advance.

  • You won't go wrong with our savory cheesecakes

    Rather than indulging in a sweet cheesecake, our savory cheesecakes are perfect to serve as an appetizer or part of the main dish. With bursts of flavor, our savory cheesecake options include vegetarian, meat and cheese, and chicken.

  • This Month's Featured Flavors

    Each Month We Feature Flavors by the Slice. For May our flavors are: Raspberry Lemon, Peachy Pecan, Strawberries & Cream, Cherry Chocolate Chip or Chocolate Covered Cherry, Caramel Swirl and Chocolate Chocolate Chip...stop in and find your new favorite flavor.

Anthony’s Heavenly Cheesecake & Cafe
Proudly Serving Evansville, IN

Hours: Monday – Saturday  8am – 8pm

Located at 919 North Park Drive in Evansville, IN, Anthony’s Heavenly Cheesecake is a specialty bakery that makes gourmet sweet and savory cheesecakes. Each is made-to-order and made from scratch. We can customize cheesecakes for all your special occasions with delivery options available as well. Our café is open for breakfast, offering delectable scones and breakfast sandwiches. Also open for light lunch or dinner options, we serve soups, salads and wraps, rolls or bowls.

Our sweet cheesecake slices are made fresh daily with a variety of flavors available. With a list of over 75 different dessert cheesecakes, you are sure to find your favorite swirl, signature, specialty, and layered cheesecakes. Please order whole cheesecakes 5 days in advance. Savory Cheesecakes are also available by the slice or whole. Order our savory cheesecakes in Minis, 4 inch, or 6 inch sizes. New flavors created all the time.

Order online today and pick up your cheesecake in the bakery before your next occasion! We look forward to seeing you soon!

  • Anthony's Heavenly Cheesecake

    919 North Park Drive
    Evansville, IN 47710


    Call Us
    Phone: 812-470-7763

    Tue: 10:00AM - 8:00PM
    Wed: 10:00AM - 8:00PM
    Thu: 10:00AM - 8:00PM
    Fri: 10:00AM - 8:00PM
    Sat: 10:00AM - 8:00PM
    Sun: Closed